The Consistency of Education & Politics; Critical Analysis of Virtuism, Powerism & Critical Theories

Document Type : پژوهشی

Authors

• Mojtaba Hematifar ¹
• Bakhtiar Shabani Varaki ¹
• Jamileh Alamolhoda ²
• sharif lakzaee ³

¹ ferdowsi university of mashhad

² Shahid beheshti university

³ Science and Islamic culture Research

10.22067/fedu.v9i1.74829

Abstract

The main aim of this research is identifying and evaluation of views about the problem of the compatibility of education and politics. To do this, we explain and formulate how education and politics relate to each other in terms of virtuism, powerism, and critical theory. To do this, we use, the means-end model in a broad sense, and also the structure-function binary in explanation of the State alongside the Spragens's Crisis theory. This study shows that three main streams are related to the philosophy of society and could be considered as a response to making compatible education and politics.: 1- "Virtuism"; with a central focus on the functional aspect of the State, the instrumental attitude to power and politics in the direction of realization of goodness and superiority (Plato, Aristotle, and some Muslim philosophers); 2- "Powerism"; with the view of the power as the intrinsic value, mainly in the form of a modern State (structure) and an instrumental attitude to education (Sophism, Hobbes and Locke); 3- Critical theory; by criticizing the structural aspect of the State and sometimes emphasizing the struggle, while adhering to the value of power (Frierre and Carnoy). In this paper, based on the analysis, comparison, and critique of these theories, we prefer to develop an alternative version of virtuous State in the line of the Islamic perspective. We conclude that changing the meaning of education and politics and distribution of power is the solution for the incompatibility between education and politics.

Keywords

• compatibility of education and politics
• virtuism
• powerism
• critical theory

---

References

Alamolhoda, J. (2012). Islamic Theory of Education (the foundations of Formal Education). Tehran: Imam Sadiq University Press (In Persian)

Ali Hosseini, A. & Ghaemi, F. (2013). The link between education and politics in ancient Greek political thought. Quarterly Journal of Political Research, No. 7, 8 – 25 (In Persian)

Ali Hossaini, A. & Ghaemi, F. (2015). A Comparative Study of Implications of Maximum links of Politics and Education in Plato's and Farabi's Virtuous Thinking. Quarterly Journal of Public Opinion Studies, No. 15, 227-250 (In Persian)

Barkhordari, R. (2015). Paulo Freire. Iranian Encyclopedia of Curriculum. Retrieved from: http://www.daneshnamehicsa.ir/userfiles/file/article/20/Dr_%20Barkhordari_6_3_93.pdf (In Persian)

Brooke, C. and Frazer, E. (2013). Introduction: Education and political theory, In (eds.). Ideas of Education: Philosophy and politics from Plato to Dewey (1-5): Routledge

Carnoy, M. (1986). Education as a Cultural Imperialism. (H. Pasha Sharifi, Trans.). Tehran: RAVESH-e NO (In Persian)

Carnoy, M. (1992). Education and the state: from Adam Smith to Perestroika, In R. F. Arnove, P. G. Altbach & G. P. Kelly (Eds.), Emergent issues in education: Comparative perspectives (pp. 143-159): State University of New York Press.

Carnoy, M. and Levin, H. M. (1988). The Limits of Educational Reform. (M. H. Teimuri, Trans.). Tehran: NASHR-e ROOZ (In Persian)

Dewey, John (1962). Democracy and Education: An Introduction to the Philosophy of Education. (A. Arianpur, Trans). Tehran: Tehran Bookstores (In Persian)

Eulau, H. (1971). Political science and education: the long view and the short, In Theory and Politics/Theorie und Politik (pp. 343-351): Springer Netherlands.

Evans, M. (2014). A Short History of Society: The Making of the Modern World. (M. Nabavi, Trans.). Tehran: AHAG (In Persian)

Fawzi, Y. and Karimi Biranvand, M. (2011). The role of government in education; a comparison of the views of Plato and Imam Khomeini. Biquarterly of Islam and Educational Research, No. 5, 133-162 (In Persian)

Freire, P. (1977). Pedagogy of the Opressed. (A. Shariatmadari, trans.). Tehran: Chappakhsh (In Persian).

Freund, J. (2002-a). Politics and Democracy, in Bozorg Naderzad (collector and Trans.) (2002). On Democracy, Education, Ethics and Politics (PP: 25-76). Tehran: Cheshmeh (In Persian)

Freund, J. (2002-b). Politics and Ethics. (Bozorg Naderzad, Trans.) (2002). On Democracy, Education, Ethics and Politics (PP: 77-102). Tehran: Cheshmeh (In Persian)

Golmohammadi, A. (2013). What, the Developpment and vision of the state. Tehran: Ney (In Persian)

Gutmann, A. (1998). Undemocratic education, In Hirst, Paul H. & White, Patricia (Hg.), Philosophy of Education. Major Themes in the Analytic Tradition, Vol. 3, 28-43.

Gutmann, A. (1999). Democratic Education: Princeton University Press.

Gutmann, A. (2003). The authority and responsibility to educate, In Randall Curren (ed.). A companion to the philosophy of education (PP: 395-411): Chicago

Illich, I. (2008). Deschooling: A denounciation of present-day schooling with radical suggestions for reform. (E. Zargham, Trans.). Tehran: Roshd (In Persian)

Islami, S.H. (2004). The relation between Ethics and politics; four theories. Quarterly Journal in the field of Islamic and Political Studies, No. 26, 141-162 (In Persian)

Jarvis, P. (2005). Adult education and the state: towards a politics of adult education: Routledge.

Javidi Kalate Jafar Abadi, T. (2009). The Philosophy of Democratic Education: Fundamentals, Principles and Methods of Education. Mashhad: Behnashr Publications (In Persian)

Jeager, W. (1997). Paedia. (M. H. Lotfi, Trans.). Tehran: Kharazmi (In Persian)

Kayre, A. (2010). Plato's politics. (Amir Hossein Jahanbegloo, Trans.). Tehran: KHARAZMI (In Persian)

Kazamias, A. M. (2007). Paideia and Politeia: Education, and the Polity/State in Comparative Education, In International handbook of comparative education (P: 161-168): Springer Netherlands

Khorasani, R. (2004). Ethics and Politics in Islamic Political Thought. Qom: Boostan Ketab (In Persian)

Khoi, LT (2010). Education, Cultures and Societies. (M. Yemeni Dozzy Sorkhi, Trans.). Tehran: Samt (In Persian)

Levin, H. M. (1988). What does educational reform mean? in Carnoy, Martin and Levin, Henry. M (writers). The Limits of Educational Reform. (M. H. Teimuri, Trans.). Tehran: ROOZ- NO (In Persian)

Machiavelli, N. (1996). The Prince (Second Edition). (D. Ashuri, Trans.). Tehran: Nashr Markaz (In Persian)

Madanifar, M. (2016). Explaining the nature and characteristics of educational research in terms of human agency (PhD thesis). University of Tehran (In Persian)

Marzouqi, R. (2000). Study of the relationship between government and education from Imam Ali's point of view. Islamic Education Quarterly, No. 4, 59-68 (In Persian)

Nabavi, S. A. (2009). Philosophy of Power. Tehran: Samt (In Persian)

Naghibzadeh Jalali, M. A. (2001). A look at the philosophy of education. Tehran: Tahori (In Persian)

Naghibzadeh Jalali, M. A. (2008). An Introduction to Philosophy. Tehran: Tahori (In Persian)

Nazerzadeh Kermani, F. (1997). A look at the history of the formation of the Greek polis and its position and importance in Plato's political philosophy. Quarterly Journal of Philosophy, No. 2, 75-86 (In Persian)

Olmos, L. E., & Torres, C. A. (2009). Theories of the state, educational expansion, development, and globalizations: Marxian and critical approaches, In R. Cowen & A. M. Kazamias (Eds.). International Handbook of Comparative Education (PP: 73-86): Springer.

Omidi, M. (2010). The Originality of virtue or the originality of power? The development of classic politics to modern politics. Sureh-e Andisheh, No. 48-49, 93-98 (In Persian)

Omidi, M. (2011). A Review of Virtuous Ethics in Classical Political Philosophy. The biannual of Political Knowledge, No. 6, 7-26 (In Persian)

Plato (1987). Plato's Series (Vol: 4 - Rules). (M. H. Lotfi, trans.). Tehran: Kharazmi Publishing Co (In Persian)

Poggi, G. (1998). The Development of the Modern State, a Sociological Introduction. (B. Bashi, Trans.). Tehran: Agah (In Persian)

Poladi, K. (2012). From the State of Authority to the Atate of reason in modern political philosophy. Tehran: Markaz (In Persian)

Sadeghzadeh Ghamsari, A. (2000). An Investigation into the Educational Responsibility of the Islamic State in the Contemporary Period Based on the Word and Action Imam Ali's (AS). Islamic Education Quarterly, No. 4, 27-58 (In Persian)

Sajjadieh, N. (2009). Mutual responsibilities of the formal education institution and the family. Hura Quarterly, No. 31 (In Persian)

Shabani Varaki, B. (2004). Education and Humanisation: Paulo Fereire's Critical Theory. Educational Innovations Quarterly, No. 8, 95-106 (In Persian)

Soroush Mahallati, M. (2007). The responsibility of Islamic government in formal education. Biquarterly Journal of Islamic Education, No. 5, 55-88 (In Persian)

Spragens, T. A. (2013). Understanding Political Theory. Tehran: AGAH (In Persian)

Szkudlarek, T. (2013). Introduction: education and the political, In Tomasz Szkudlarek (Ed.). Education and the Political: New Theoretical Articulations (pp.1-13): Sense Publishers.

Taylor, C. C. W. & Lee, M. (2016). The Sophists, In Edward N. Zalta (ed.). The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Winter 2016 Edition), retrieved from: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/sophists

Torres, C. A. (1995). State and education revisited: Why educational researchers should think politically about education, In Review of research in education (Vol. 21, PP: 255-331). American Educational Research Association.

Vereker, C. (1976). Public Benefits, Private Vices: The Impact of Politics on Education. Oxford Review of Education, 2 (1): 49-58.

Zoelm, A. (2003). The position of education in the political thought of Imam Khomeini. The Congress of the Mystical-Ethical Thoughts of Imam Khomeini, Qom (In Persian)